Posts Tagged ‘Accurizing’

AR-MPR: Accurizing the Upper Receiver – Test Results

Sunday, July 3rd, 2011

In the following posts:

I’ve documented an experiment in accurizing the upper receiver of the AR-MPR rifle. It was a bit painful to file away hard anodizing, followed by drilling, welding, milling, and finally epoxy bedding. The whole point was to remove slop between the upper and lower receivers on the AR-MPR rifle.

I finally had a chance to test out the rifle with the modifications in place. I did a quick sight-in on the paper at 25 yards, then dialed it in at 100 yards. From a bipod and rigged up rear rest, the first 5-shot group measured just .604″ (.577 MOA) – well within the .5-.75 MOA goal for the project.

The first 100 yard 5-shot group with the accurized AR-MPR rifle - Image Copyright 2011 Ultimate Reloader

Next, I’m looking forward to shooting off a proper rest, and experimenting with different loads to see how good this rifle can get.

I’m confident that this rifle will continue to turn in more great groups. Stay tuned, because there’s another related project coming up!

-Gavin

AR-MPR: Accurizing the Upper Receiver – Part II: Milling and Receiver Face Truing

Tuesday, June 14th, 2011

In this post, I’ll finish covering the accurizing steps and experiments for the AR-MPR upper receiver- so far, we’ve covered the following:

Following the welding process, I carefully milled and measured the sides of the upper receiver lugs. The result was centered lugs that measured about .504″ wide. I then used dye and a file to carefully hand fit the lugs so that the upper receiver requires a slight press fit to be mated with the lower receiver.

Milling down the welded area of the lugs - Image Copyright 2011 Ultimate Reloader

The next challenge was locating the holes in the upper receiver lugs and drilling them. I machined a 1/4″ diameter guide with a 1/8″ through hole to allow a 1/8″ drill be to be used for this locating process. I started the holes with a hand drill, and then clamped the upper receiver in the milling machine to finish the drilling process. In order to get an accurate position, I used a 1/8″ locator rod in a collet to dial in the position of the spindle. I then drilled at 1/8″ and then an undersize (less than .250″) hole followed that. Finally, I used a 1/4″ end mill to finish the hole. This drilling was done .004″ offset (excessively tight fit for upper and lower) so that a hand reamer could be used to dial in the upper and lower fit.

Custom drill pilot - Image Copyright 2011 Ultimate Reloader

This process mostly worked. I did end up with some slight slop in the mating of the upper and lower. So I decided to epoxy bed the upper and lower to take up the mating slack. This process involves filing the mating surface of the upper, coating the lower with wax (I used Imperial Case Sizing Wax) applying the epoxy, and then mating the upper and lower with an Accu-Wedge in place. Nerve racking, but with a slight prying action, the upper separated from the lower easily following the curing process.

The result- a totally slop free fit between the upper and lower.

The final step was to machine an upper receiver truing mandrel from a 1″ section of cold rolled roundbar stock and to true the upper receiver face. This results in better alignment (less optics adjustment for sight in) and hopefully a more consistent barrel position from shot to shot.

Custom Receiver Mandrel - Image Copyright 2011 Ultimate Reloader

The result was a nicely machined face for the barrel extension to press against when the barrel nut is locked down. We’ll see if this helps when it’s time to sight in the rifle once again.

Trued Upper Receiver Face - Image Copyright 2011 Ultimate Reloader

I’m looking forward to trying out the AR-MPR rifle with these improvements. I am anticipating that these accurizing steps will help with consistency and accuracy, but I don’t know how much they will help. I’ll have to find out!

I’ll give an update when I have more data.

Thanks,
Gavin

 

AR-MPR: Accurizing the Upper Receiver – Part I: Prep and Welding

Tuesday, June 7th, 2011

In my last post, outlined some ideas and goals for talking the slop out of the fit between the upper and lower receivers on the AR-MPR rifle. The first step is to remove the gaps between the sides of the upper receiver lugs, and the channels at the front and back of the lower receiver. With approximately .017″ of total slop (front gap + rear gap), that would equate to approximately 8″ of  hypothetical variation in point of impact (if the receiver could twist fully in each direction).                                .

While I contemplated bedding the lugs with the receiver with epoxy, I decided that since the lugs are bearing surfaces when the upper and lower are opened/closed, this could cause wear with a “softer” material like epoxy. I am looking for a more long-term fix.

The experiment:

Based on the goals, and the tools that I have on hand, I decided to remove the hard coating and weld the lug holes shut, leaving excess aluminum “raised up” that could be milled down to the proper dimensions. While not as ideal as hard coating, the aluminum should prove reasonably resistant to wear and tear.

Step 1: Prep the Surfaces

I did two things to remove the hardcoat (anodizing) from the lug surfaces where welding would take place. First, I filed down the sides of the lugs. I was amazed at just how hard the hardcoat treatment is. It felt more difficult than filing mild steel by far! Second, I drilled out the holes to remove the hardcoat from the insides of the holes. Again, I was amazed at how hard the harcoat treatment was to drill – in fact, I had to sharpen the HSS drill bit a couple times to get the job done. Drill Doctor to the rescue!

Rear lug prepped for welding - Image Copyright 2011 Ultimate Reloader

Step 2: Weld the Lugs

I’ll admit- using my Lincoln Powermig 200 for this job was a bit of overkill  – in fact, I would have preferred using a TIG welder (something I’ve yet to try) – but I thought this would be worth a try.

The welder - A customized Lincoln Powermig 200 - Image Copyright 2011 Ultimate Reloader

MIG welding aluminum? Don’t forget your spool gun! I used 100% argon gas and my spoolgun for this welding job. I don’t weld aluminum frequently, so I had to experiment on a test piece, and put on a split tip. Once I got things setup, it was time to go.

Aluminum welding spoolgun - Image Copyright 2011 Ultimate Reloader

Welding aluminum is very exacting- it’s not like welding steel where you have a high degree of flexibility on temperature, and can see the temperature by examining the color of the weld puddle (Red = Cold, Yellow = Hot). With aluminum, you have a response more like microwaving butter. All solid one second, melted through the next second. You really have to watch the shininess of the edges of the puddle, and practice a lot.

Overall, the welding went well using quick “blasts”. As I expected, the corners rounded off a bit due to the high intensity of heat.

Lug after welding – Image Copyright 2011 Ultimate Reloader

The result was not perfect, but given the tools at hand, and the experimental nature of this project, I felt the outcome was acceptable. Next, we’ll cover milling the sides of the lugs, and re-drilling the holes.

AR-MPR: Accurizing the Upper Receiver – Overview

Thursday, June 2nd, 2011

A while back, I posted some AR-MPR rifle accurizing plans. This was my first-pass at enhancing the accuracy of the AR-MPR rifle. Since this post, I have had a few range visits (sorry, don’t have photos as the range does not permit photography) where I did not see the kind of accuracy and consistency that I experienced during the first range visit.

There are many factors that can affect accuracy for an AR-15 rifle, and one of them is the fit between the upper receiver and the lower receiver. This is (like anything else regarding rifle accuracy) quite controversial – but if there’s a bunch of slop between the upper and lower, you’re bound to get less consistent results. Based on the amount of slop present on this rifle, I decided to experiment with some techniques that I have either read about or devised on my own to tighten up the upper and lower.

Truing the face of the upper receiver on a metal lathe - Image Copyright 2011 Ultimate Reloader

So how did I decide that there was too much slop? Well, I started with a basic rocking of the upper assembly, and felt (qualitatively) that there was just too much slop. Following this, I dug in deeper to take some measurements. Measuring the channels for the lugs in the lower receiver, I found they were .502″ wide. The lugs on the upper receiver however measured about .495″ for the front, and .485″ in the back. That meant about .007″ of slop in the front, and .017″ of slop in the rear! Even an Accuwedge won’t fix that! In addition, there was a noticeable gap between the upper and lower- meaning that the holes in the lugs were too far “down” vertically to allow for a tight fit.

The concept I had was to modify the lugs so that they would fit the upper and lower receiver tighter together. I have a MIG welder setup for aluminum welding, a milling machine, and a metal lathe. What could go wrong? :)

In following posts, I’ll walk through the procedures that I undertook to tighten the upper and lower receiver, summarize results, and talk about what worked and what did not. While I was at it, I decided to true the face of the upper receiver that mates up with the barrel extension – see the above image. (This included making a custom mandrel for the metal lathe for upper receiver turning).

Stay tuned!

-Gavin

AR-MPR: Phase II – Rifle Accurizing Plans

Wednesday, March 2nd, 2011

I just read a great article written by Robert Whitley of www.6mmar.com fame that was posted on the  http://accurateshooter.com blog:

What Makes an AR Accurate — Whitley Offers Answers

Talk about good timing! This post helped me plan the first wave of accurizing activities for the AR-MPR rifle. My goal is to remove any factors that will prevent consistent groups – part of that is related to precision handloading, another part is related to the rifle and related equipment, and finally- shooting techniques and skill. In this post, I’ll outline some plans I have for addressing the second group of concerns listed here.

Let’s walk through the first pass at these accurizing activities:

Improved Stock

The AR-MPR currently wears a standard 6-Position collapsible stock. I thought this would be nice for compactness when carrying in the field, and so that it would be easily stowable/storable. I was a bit concerned that this stock would be too wobbly- and it does indeed impose more movement than is acceptable. The answer is to upgrade to a Magpul PRS adjustable stock- this stock was designed for this type of use, so this should help tighten up the back half of the rifle, and afford optimal shooting ergonomics. The flat bottom will be ideal for riding straight back in the rear rest.

The Magpul PRS Precision Adjustable Stock - Click for product page

The Accu-Wedge

One of the simple upgrades that you can make for your accuracy-minded AR-15 is a drop in part called the “Accu-Wedge”. The purpose is simple- take the wobble between the upper and lower units away. No, this wedge does not make the upper “rock-solid” against the lower, but it does help to keep it steady – which translates to keeping your groups tighter!

The Accu-Wedge - Click for product listing at Brownells

Front Bench Rest Rider (Custom)

In order to complement the Magpul PRS – I’m planning to machine a custom front bench rest rider. This will clamp onto the bottom rail of the handguard, and will allow the rifle to move straight backwards under recoil rather than “jumping up”. More details to follow on this project!

This project was inspired by the EGW bag-rider (great if you have a round handguard):

EGW Bag-Rider System

These improvements, combined with precision loading and load experimentation should enable me to shoot tighter groups more consistently. My goal is to be able to consistently shoot .5″ 5-shot groups from this rifle off the bench rest.

Anything I’m missing here? Please comment!

Stay tuned!